Hearing In Philly Continues On Lap Dance Tax - FOX 13 News

Hearing In Philly Continues On Lap Dance Tax

Posted: Updated:
PHILADELPHIA -

The Nutter administration has decided that so-called lap dances should be subject to the city's five percent amusement tax.

The city's tax review board will ultimately decide whether lap dances, those up close and personal, one-on-one performances by dancers, are subject to the amusement tax.

But at today's hearing we got to see what lots of business owners complain about: a lack of consistency, and predictability, in tax policy.

Back in 2006, the city's revenue department audited the books at Club Risque on South Columbus Boulevard.

They made sure the club was paying its "amusement tax." Remember, this was under the Street administration and it was pre-recession. With that in mind, listen to this exchange between George Bochetto, the lawyer representing the club, and Ted Pagano, a club Risque advisor.

"What did they assess the amusement tax on?" says Bochetto.

"On the admission charge," responds Pagano.

"Did they assess at that point any amusement tax on any of the lap dances which were all disclosed through all the records?" asks Bochetto.

"Not that I'm aware of," answers Pagano.

"And did the city, in 2006, in any way, shape or form, indicate that lap dances may be the subject to the amusement tax?" asks Bochetto.

"Not at all," answers Pagano.

The club was audited again in 2012, this time with Michael Nutter as mayor and an economy still reeling from recession. This time, says Pagano, the club received a bill for well over $300,000, amusement tax on lap dances plus interest and penalties.

"They blind-sided us with the notion that there should have been a tax on lap dances," says Pagano.

"This is the same audit department from the same city of Philadelphia that was there in 2006, right?" asks Bochetto. "Same ones," answers Pagano.

"If Club Risque were forced to pay that money for back taxes, could they afford to do so?"asks Bochetto.

"No."

"What would happen to that business?"

"It'd be in big trouble," predicts Pagano.

That wasn't the only hit the city took: a deputy solicitor was roundly criticized at today's hearing for questioning a witness for the strip clubs about his own business tax bills. He was suggesting they were overdue.

Review board members said the line of questioning was out of bounds, irrelevant to this case. And Attorney Bochetto exploded, accusing the city of trying to embarrass and intimidate those who question their tax bills.

No ruling on this case yet, but things are getting tense.

  • Bruce Gordon ReportsMore>>

  • New Video Game Sparks Debate In South Jersey

    New Video Game Sparks Debate In South Jersey

    Friday, August 1 2014 5:30 PM EDT2014-08-01 21:30:49 GMT
    Video games may be pure fantasy, but a violent action-adventure game called "Watch Dogs" has ignited a very real debate in one South Jersey community. Watch Dog allows players to adopt the persona of a James Bond-like computer hacker, chasing an evil mastermind. People say it's chock-full of foul language, sex and violence, features dark and foreboding backdrops. The latest version, which is due out this fall may be set in Camden.
    Video games may be pure fantasy, but a violent action-adventure game called "Watch Dogs" has ignited a very real debate in one South Jersey community. Watch Dog allows players to adopt the persona of a James Bond-like computer hacker, chasing an evil mastermind. People say it's chock-full of foul language, sex and violence, features dark and foreboding backdrops. The latest version, which is due out this fall may be set in Camden.

  • Feds: 6 Philly Narcotic Cops Robbed, Kidnapped Drug Dealers

    Feds: 6 Philly Narcotic Cops Robbed, Kidnapped Drug Dealers

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 1:20 PM EDT2014-07-30 17:20:24 GMT

    Six former members of the Philadelphia Police Dept.'s narcotics unit have been federally indicted, charged with using robbery, kidnapping and other tactics to shake down more than $500,000 in cash, property and drugs from suspected drug dealers.

    Six former members of the Philadelphia Police Dept.'s narcotics unit have been federally indicted, charged with using robbery, kidnapping and other tactics to shake down more than $500,000 in cash, property and drugs from suspected drug dealers.

  • SEPTA Rider: Couple With Toddler Seemed "Out Of It" On Train

    SEPTA Rider: Couple With Toddler Seemed "Out Of It" On Train

    Wednesday, July 30 2014 12:55 AM EDT2014-07-30 04:55:19 GMT
    Camera-phone video captured a disturbing scene aboard a SEPTA subway train. The video shows a shoeless toddler in a stroller and witnesses say the adults with her seem to be "out of it." The couple was on a train on the Market-Frankford Line on Sunday morning.


    Camera-phone video captured a disturbing scene aboard a SEPTA subway train. The video shows a shoeless toddler in a stroller and witnesses say the adults with her seem to be "out of it." The couple was on a train on the Market-Frankford Line on Sunday morning.

  • Local NewsMore>>

  • Police: Boater Disappearance May Have Been Staged

    Police: Boater Disappearance May Have Been Staged

    Friday, August 1 2014 6:28 PM EDT2014-08-01 22:28:19 GMT
    Egg Harbor Township Police believe the disappearance of a boater in July may have been staged.
    Egg Harbor Township Police believe the disappearance of a boater in July may have been staged.
  • New Video Game Sparks Debate In South Jersey

    New Video Game Sparks Debate In South Jersey

    Friday, August 1 2014 5:30 PM EDT2014-08-01 21:30:49 GMT
    Video games may be pure fantasy, but a violent action-adventure game called "Watch Dogs" has ignited a very real debate in one South Jersey community. Watch Dog allows players to adopt the persona of a James Bond-like computer hacker, chasing an evil mastermind. People say it's chock-full of foul language, sex and violence, features dark and foreboding backdrops. The latest version, which is due out this fall may be set in Camden.
    Video games may be pure fantasy, but a violent action-adventure game called "Watch Dogs" has ignited a very real debate in one South Jersey community. Watch Dog allows players to adopt the persona of a James Bond-like computer hacker, chasing an evil mastermind. People say it's chock-full of foul language, sex and violence, features dark and foreboding backdrops. The latest version, which is due out this fall may be set in Camden.

  • SOGGY WEEKEND

    Friday, August 1 2014 5:24 PM EDT2014-08-01 21:24:23 GMT

    Saturday will start off unsettled, especially S&E, but towards the afternoon most of us should remain drier with light scattered showers.

    Saturday (79/68): AM Rain, PM Clouds

    Weekend, clouds will stick around throughout Saturday and Sunday as wet weather dampens the first weekend in August. Saturday will start off unsettled, especially S&E, but towards the afternoon most of us should remain drier with light scattered showers. There is a better chance for more widespread precipitation Sunday with on and off showers/thunderstorms possible.

    Saturday (79/68): AM Rain PM Clouds

    Sunday (81/68): Cloudy, Showers & T-Storms

Powered by WorldNow

FOX 13 / WTVT-TV
3213 West Kennedy Blvd.
Tampa, Florida 33609
Main: (813) 876-1313
Newsroom: (813) 870-9630
Fax: (813) 871-3135

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | New Terms of Service What's new | Ad Choices