Updated: Tuesday, 16 Jun 2009, 5:15 PM EDT
Published : Tuesday, 16 Jun 2009, 10:01 AM EDT
CARROLLWOOD - Part of a fallen New York City firefighter's Medal of Valor has been stolen from his mother's home in Carrollwood. And despite two arrests, investigators have been unable to recover it.
"I'm sure they don't know what it was. To them it might not be worth much, but to us it is priceless," said Brian Muldowney, whose brother Richie was awarded the medal for his sacrifice on September 11, 2001.
The Muldowney family says the medal itself is safe with Richie's widow in New York. Two pins that came with the medal were stolen in March.
Hillsborough deputies last week accused Carlos Pierce and Alicia Sanders of the burglary, but sheriff's spokesperson J.D. Callaway said Monday the pair has refused to make statements about the whereabouts of the pins.
"Just tell us where it's at," said Brian Muldowney, the brother. "You've already broke into my mom's house. Now you steal this? Just fess it up."
Muldowney, also a firefighter, said he his optimistic that putting his brother Richie's story on television will help.
"I've got my fingers crossed. All you can do is hope that someone who's watching knows somebody that has it."
Anyone with information about the pins or the burglary can call CrimeStoppers at 1-800-873-TIPS and leave an anonymous tip.